KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 27 — Malaysia has allowed hip-hop group Black Eyed Peas to play at Arthur's Day in Sunway Lagoon on Sept 25 — one of four official global spots celebrating Guinness Stout's 250th anniversary — but only for non-Muslims.
The Information, Communication and Culture Ministry had put in this condition, apart from telling the brewery not to put any logos or sell the bitter-sweet brew at the concert which also features local act Reshmonu, several bands and deejays.
It is learnt that music concert rules disallow breweries or alcoholic drinks makers from sponsoring such events but the ministry relented as the concert is expected to boost the tourism industry affected by the recession and the A(H1N1) flu outbreak.
A sentence in the local Arthur's Day website — www.arthursday.com.my — states the event is only for non-Muslims aged 18 and above. The concert at the Sunway Lagoon Surf Beach costs RM103 an entry.
Kuala Lumpur is the Asia-Pacific venue for Arthur's Day, celebrating founder Arthur Guinness who opened the brewery in Dublin in 1759 with a 9,000-year lease and is now one of the world's most recognisable brands. Malaysia, which prides itself for being a Muslim nation, is one of the top 10 Guinness consuming countries in the world with the bitter available everywhere.
Apart from the Kuala Lumpur concert, Guinness is organising concerts in hometown Dublin and London apart from events in Australia, Canada, Indonesia and the United States.
The restrictions on Muslims comes on the back of the suspended caning for a Muslim mother-of-two caught drinking beer, PAS protests against beer sales at convenience outlets in Selangor and the Michael Learns To Rock concert in Genting Highlands on Sept 5 which falls during the current Ramadan fasting month.
Both PAS and Umno, the dominant party in the ruling Barisan Nasional federal government, have been at pains to flash their Islamic credentials for the crucial Malay vote.
Information, Communications and Culture Minister Datuk Seri Rais Yatim last month came under attack for proposing an Internet filter ostensibly to cut out cyberspace pornography although critics said it was to police online dissent.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak stopped the tender for the Internet filter which authorities said was actually a survey to gauge a feasibility for such a filter. Najib also criticised a syariah court ruling to cane Kartika Sari Dewi Shukarno for drinking beer, urging her to appeal against the sentence.
The ruling to shut out Muslims from the Black Eyed Peas concert is strange as they last performed to an unrestricted audience in Malaysia in late 2007. The Black-Eyed Peas is riding high in the charts with their “Boom Boom Pow” single from their latest album “The E.N.D” which stands for The Energy Never Dies.
Malaysia has played host to several international acts over the years but pop sensation Beyonce Knowles shelved her Malaysian concert also in late 2007 and went to perform in Indonesia after pressure to cover up and tone down what was seen as a sexually-provocative performance.
However, singer Gwen Stefani dressed modestly during her concert in 2007 while organisers for the Pussy Cat Dolls concert in Sunway Lagoon were fined for their sexy performance in 2006.
Guinness has organised a global celebration for Arthur's Day which starts in Dublin at 1759 GMT on Sept 24 (1.59am Malaysian time, Sept 25) with glasses being raised to Arthur Guinness in over 150 countries.
According to its www.g250years.com celebration website, there will be spectacular events in major cities like New York to intimate affairs at bars or pubs.
In Canada, there will be a string of black carpet VIP parties from Vancouver, home of the 2010 Winter Olympics, through to Toronto, Ottawa and Halifax.
Australians can party at each major state capital city in what it termed are iconic Guinness venues while in Indonesia, there will be a bus safari travelling through 10 of its key cities from October.

written by whatsayyou, August 27, 2009
written by Noel, August 27, 2009
Eventually there are endless combination :
1) websites for non-muslim
2) TV programme for non-muslim
3) Airline for non-muslim
There is one only sun and we live under one roof .. but human creates so much restrictions ..
written by bluesinger, August 27, 2009
Might as well partition the dem country
written by jocker, August 27, 2009
for the locals? how to go if maybe your best friend cannot?...1malaysia? i feel sorry for the prime minister and his attempt at unity here with 1malaysia.
written by mat taib, August 27, 2009
Be consistent rais, issue a directive NO MORE RAYA CELEBRATIONS BY NON-MUSLIMS!
So much for najib's 1 umno...ha ha ha
written by mat taib, August 27, 2009
written by jtan, August 27, 2009
written by Jefus, August 27, 2009
hello,....
written by ckh, August 27, 2009
written by OngOnG, August 27, 2009
written by John, August 27, 2009
written by Fender Stratocaster, August 27, 2009
written by max weber, August 27, 2009
Muslims have their own way of life which evidently you can see when holy month of Ramadhan comes.. Muslims
written by werra, August 27, 2009
written by Regnum Defende, August 27, 2009
written by foodforthought, August 27, 2009
written by fedddup, August 27, 2009
Hey man, its all in your own HEART. Your iman, your aqidah, your own heart. Not what others did nor what you have done to stop others from. When you die, you answer to God. God is not going to say, "You good man, you stop them from attending that concert. Now go to heaven".
written by Guamian, August 27, 2009
I am all out for the boycott, don't let one concert draw the line between us. Mind you I'm a true fan of the BEP's but this sort of conditions just does not do it.
Send the message across loud and clear. We are as ONE.
written by matureman07, August 27, 2009
It has becoming a major problem for the authorities to encroach into family decisions. There are families with different values. Leave it to them to decide on matter like this. The authorities should focus on serious matter like increase in criminals activities over the past few years. Corruptions and abuse of power. Things like what to watch, what to drink and eat, where to go and what how to dress please leave that to the people to decide on their own.
written by joker, August 27, 2009
i feel sorry for the PM and his noble attempt at 1 malaysia, ruined by his underlings.
the current political situation has all the parties competing to be the most islamic to attract the malay vote...its a downward spiral and it will end with taliban style rulings if this is not sorted out.
its such a shame that this is played out by the ruling elite, as all the malay/chinese/indian friends i have are so nice and moderate.....in my day to day life i do see a 1malaysia, but sadly not in the political scene.
written by Suri, August 27, 2009
written by pad, August 27, 2009
If I were Guinness management, I will move the concert to Singapore or Thailand.
written by RacialHarmony, August 27, 2009
written by Sophia, August 27, 2009
written by maozee, August 27, 2009
Apartheid Rules, Baby ! Thank you Najib for 1Malaysia. But then it's better than PAS !! No MLTR ..... Thank God i am not Muslim !!
written by malaysian at heart, August 27, 2009
-Not to sell beers there
Big deal?they can just get it somewhere else before the concert. so what's the ban all about?
-No non muslim for the concert
So they are going to go through the process of identifying individuals who purchase the ticket?how are they going to do that?another waste of money..unnecessary screening process!
I don't think the government has to forbid them. After all if they drink, then this will be between them and god. Why bother wasting time screening events?
It's always ironic to me, that Malaysia still has rape cases...I know you can't curb this, but, pfft....
written by bbz, August 27, 2009
written by Pgite, August 27, 2009
Is this where we are going?
Many have commented our neighbours from the south- Indonesia. Many have been there and know how much more progressive and liberal they are compared to what we have here. We have a bunch of zealots from Umno and PAS on one side and a bunch of pseudo-liberals on the other side.
Religion is a personal thing. Why must they force it down their throats? It's not going to make them anymore religious. The more you force, the more they will rebel.
And enough of the double standards. Go catch some Defenders of the Faith first then make them an an example rather than some model/nurse/housewife.
written by How2Read, August 27, 2009
Is this your first step in forcing religion down your own believers to make them move further away?
written by -, August 27, 2009
Indonesia is enroute to overtaking us, so soon you may soon have to eat your own words about it being less developed than Malaysia. Our neighbouring country is improving in leaps and bounds due to a progressive change in outlook.
written by young muslim constituent, August 27, 2009
Why alcohol ads are everywhere displayed to Muslims (showing it as a lifestyle and chic product when to Muslims it bring more disaster than good), when cigarettes are banned from even been displayed without all the gory looking images that make even normal nonsmokers shake like a zombie? Like practicing Muslims are not supposed to be the readers of the Sun or the NST or the Star... maybe we are lumped into 'conservative' category that only listen to what Utusan says.
Banning alcohol in convenience stores or not allowing open drinking ALL depends on the stakeholders there affected by these actions, whether they want it to be banned or not, does it matter to others? It's democracy and public participation at work.
We have to see the level of involvement, whether alcohol holds a majority stake in any establishment, before we can go ahead and say, hey, it is time for us, practicing Muslims, to refrain from supporting these kind of stuffs.
As Muslims, when you walk in Hj Ismail duty free shop in Langkawi you still see plenty of wine bottles but when you purchase the goods there, are you personally responsible in supporting the shopowner's profit taking from goods that are clearly FORBIDDEN by God? Suma kedai duty free pun jual wine maaa, mana lagi mau cari coklat murah... But then if you, as a practicing Muslim, have a choice whether to shop at a beer-free store or not, definitely you are responsible if you still support the shopowner who sells beer.
written by mikeyboy, August 27, 2009
Also using the same perverse logic then Muslims cant use airplanes (they sell alcohol on-board) or any establishment, not just pubs or clubs but restaurants, that openly sells alcohol. To me it looks like yet another knee jerk reaction to appease the conservatives and will probably be overturned.
written by ColDam, August 27, 2009
Quite sad, really...
written by marbl3s, August 27, 2009
written by Sheik, August 27, 2009
By denying Muslims the right to choose is, really is in my opinion, the greatest wrong / sin that can be committed. Muslims are not from the dark ages anymore, at least not the Muslims in this country. This is not Pakistan or Afghanistan. This is Malaysia! A multiracial and multi religious country. So how has it come to this stage where the government has to discriminate against it's own Muslim population.
Perhaps this situation that is unfolding now will start some minds to think about the choice of their faith. Perhaps some Muslims will now seriously think about changing their faith. What have they got to loose? As a non-Muslim I can pretty much do anything I want, no restrictions on what I drink or eat, how I dress or who I'm sleeping with. It's all about choices and that's what every Muslim in this country is deprived of. How does one evolve to greater heights and wisdom if you cannot make choices on your own? It's only when we make mistakes can we learn from them. You cannot learn from other peoples mistakes.
So dear Muslims, you have to make your own choices. God gave you intelligence so that you can make up your own mind. That was God's greatest gift to mankind. That's what sets us apart from animals. So think. It is your god given right!
So are you going for the concert?
written by Cheeese, August 27, 2009
I dont see whats wrong with Michael Learns to Rock or Black Eyed Peas.
Besides,please give people to have the freedom to choose and mingle around,rather than forcing them or segregate everyone based on their religion.
written by randomthoughts, August 27, 2009
written by Anon C, August 28, 2009
written by Anon C, August 28, 2009
written by Anon C, August 28, 2009
written by Another half past six policy from BN, August 28, 2009
This concert is only sponsored by Guiness, they are not serving their beers there. This BN govt has no common sense ..... next time I am sure the organisers will go to Spore or Thailand, or Indonesia.
written by AlienAte, August 28, 2009
Many have said, religion is personal and should not be forced. If one is strong in one's beliefs, one shouldn't worry about this.
We must also practice an open minded way of looking at this. We as non-Muslim, should not interfere with our Muslim friends and let their own religious leaders do their work. Our Muslim friends who are pious or against such activities can make their own decisions. Many of them educated and informed enough.
written by Juarez Salih Lowe, August 28, 2009
1) Are they going to have to have a mykad reader to check religion before issuing tickets?
2) Will they also ban the sale of the Guinness Book of World Records to non- Muslims?
3) Should Muslims be banned from purchasing products from LVMH (which is after all a company that sells alcohol)?
Before a decision is made (and announced) it would benefit from some thorough research and thought. That would help avoid such situations where Malaysia is again in the international news for the wrong reasons (recently Malaysia was in the news for the caning of the woman who drank beer). This decision is hardly one that will help foster unity or enhance the image of Malaysia as a modern and tolerant Muslim nation.
written by Nirmal, August 28, 2009
When a liquor company cannot stage an event in the country, why did the Government approve this anyway? For the benefit of tourism? So is it for money? The Government can cross the line for money and own benefits. But individuals cannot. Wonderful, isn't it?
written by yeo kien kiong, September 02, 2009
written by It's OK, September 02, 2009
written by anakMERDEKA, September 02, 2009
NOT SO FAIR LA
written by guy, September 14, 2009
written by arisae, September 26, 2009
and for non-muslims..
it is really bothering u all by this statement???
heh.. thinkin'..thinkin'...
written by lepat, September 27, 2009
To me, there are two possible solutions to the problem:
1) Organize a BEP's concert, but not in conjunction with Arthur's Day.
2) If the govn. insist of bringing Arthur's Day to Malaysia, not making it public event is wise.
To you guys out there, who are "really" talking about 1Malaysia, this is my advice to you...
Please, please understand the rationale behind the restriction (muslim restriction, the malay culture and the holy month of Ramadhan itself). Lack of understanding about other religions and races; as well as the eagerness to condemn and tunjuk pandai about 1Malaysia (short-term as kiasu) brought up stupidity and sillynous in everyone. Don't you agree?
I'm not saying I'm against the event nor supporting it, but with better understanding comes the tolerancy. From there, the country will once again become peace and united. :)




